This lists which New-WWE superstar had the highest percentage of wins in Season 5.
Please note the following
- The superstars who debuted on New-WWE Superstars Episode 6 (Jacob Cass, Ryan Nitro, Craig David, and Daniel Bryan) are not counted on this list, as each have only had one match. Their only match was a win for all of them, and this would be unfair to factor in.
- If two superstars' percentage is tied, the one who had more matches in the season will be ranked above. If that is tied as well, the one who had greater accomplishments will be ranked higher.
- Percentages are not rounded; there may be some minor inaccuracies as a result.
- For accomplishments, only things won during Season 5 count; reigns continued from Season 4 do not count.